All U.S. employers need to verify that new hires are legally authorized to work in the United States by completing Form I-9 and, in some cases, using E-Verify.
How Gusto helps
We help you create, fill out, upload, and store the I-9 during onboarding. You and your employee fill out the I-9 together, and you keep it in your records. We do not file Form I-9 with the government.
If you add E-Verify, Gusto can also guide your new hire through a remote I-9, connect to your E-Verify account, and create cases from your I-9. Learn more in Have Gusto handle verification through E-Verify below.
Form I-9
Use Form I-9 to prove that each person you hire can work in the United States. Your employee must complete Section 1 by their first day of work. You must complete Section 2 within 3 business days of their start date.
E-Verify
If an employee is in a state that requires E-Verify (for some or all employers), you’ll need to complete it. These states require e-Verify enrollment (as of November 24, 2025):
Alabama, Arizona, Florida, Georgia, Idaho*, Indiana*, Louisiana, Michigan*, Minnesota*, Mississippi, Missouri*, Nebraska*, North Carolina, Oklahoma*, Pennsylvania*, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas*, Utah, Virginia*, and West Virginia*. *e-Verify is only required for public contractors and employees of government agencies.
Always check your state’s latest e-Verify rules. Learn more below.
Form I-9 (Employment Eligibility Verification) proves that a new hire is allowed to work in the United States.
Admins can create Form I-9s for employees who are self-onboarded or employer-onboarded (with any start date—past, present, or future).
To create someone's I-9 when adding them as a new hire through self-onboarding:
In Gusto, set up self-onboarding for the employee.
If you send an offer letter: After the new employee accepts it, they have the opportunity to fill out the I-9 after they onboard.
Click the checkbox next to Form I-9.
During self-onboarding, the new employee will enter their own personal details and sign documents, including Form I-9.
To create someone's I-9 when you add them to Gusto as a new hire through employer-led onboarding:
Step 7 of onboarding is the Documents section. This lists the standard onboarding documents we'll send the employee, including the I-9. You can add or remove documents using the checkboxes.
Once employer-led onboarding is complete, the employee receives a dashboard notification to complete the onboarding forms, including the I-9 if you selected it.
If you chose not to send an I-9 when you onboarded an employee, you can send one at any time afterward as long as the employee does not already have an I-9 on file (a Gusto I-9, a Remote I-9, or an uploaded I-9).
To send Form I-9 after onboarding:
Go to the employee's profile.
Click Documents.
Click Send I-9.
Choose how you want to verify the employee's identity and work eligibility:
Remote verification — the employee completes their part, then a reviewer they nominate examines their documents in person and completes Section 2 as your authorized representative.
In-person verification — the employee completes their part, then you review their documents in person and complete your part in Gusto.
The employee will receive a notification to complete the I-9. Once they sign their part, you'll get a dashboard notification.
The law says your employee needs to fill out their portion of the I-9 by their start date. You then have 3 business days from their start date to review their documents and complete your portion.
After the employee finishes self-onboarding, or an employer-onboarded employee fills out their portion of the I-9, you’ll get email and homepage reminders to complete your part of Form I-9.
To complete Form I-9:
On the employee's start date, sign in to your Gusto admin account.
Click the Complete Employee I-9 sticky note.
You can also get here by going to the employee's onboarding checklist.
Review your new employee’s proof of identification documents that they have physically given to you.
For more info on the required documents, read the Eligibility document requirements section of this article.
Select which identification and work authorization documents you reviewed.
Click Save & Continue.
Enter the information from the identification and work authorization documents.
Click Save & Continue.
Enter your full name and your title at the company. Select I agree to electronically sign this form.
Click Sign.
If you chose not to send the I-9 form when an employee was onboarded, you'll get a dashboard notification and an onboarding checklist task to upload the completed form.
Download a blank copy of the Form I-9
If you need a copy of Form I-9 to send to your employee to fill out:
On your dashboard, find the Complete [employee name]'s I-9 sticky note. Click the three dots icon.
You can also get here by going to the employee's onboarding checklist and finding the task called Complete [employee name]'s I-9.
Click Download form.
Once the employee completes the form and returns it to you, you can upload it to Gusto.
Upload a completed I-9 to Gusto
To add a completed I-9 to an employee's profile:
On your dashboard, click the Complete Employee I-9 sticky note.
You can also get here by going to the employee's onboarding checklist and finding the task called Complete [employee name]'s I-9.
Click Upload.
Select +Upload to attach a document.
Click the checkbox to verify that the file uploaded is an accurate copy of the original documents presented by the employee.
Click Save.
This saves the form to the Documents section of the employee’s profile and marks the task as done.
Mark the I-9 task as done without uploading the document
If you need to mark someone's I-9 task as done without uploading anything to Gusto, follow these steps:
Click People.
Choose Onboarding.
Find the name of the employee and click View checklist.
Find the task called Complete [employee name]'s I-9 and click the three dots icon.
Click Mark as done.
If you need to edit the I-9, you’ll have to do it outside of Gusto. Once done, upload the corrected version to your employee's profile. Check out the USCIS website for best practices when correcting an I-9.
If you hire a remote employee, you need to complete Form I-9 with them by their start date. The form verifies their identity and eligibility to work in the U.S.
Employers need to check the employee's identification and eligibility documents. You have three ways to handle it. Expand the section below that fits:
Check documents yourself: You or your authorized representative examine the documents in person, or by live video if your company uses E-Verify.
Use Gusto’s remote verification tool: Your new hire nominates a reviewer who examines their documents in person.
Have Gusto handle verification through E-Verify: The same remote verification tool, and we also create the E-Verify case for you.
You need to check your employee's identification and eligibility documents. You have two ways to do this yourself:
Work with your remote new hire to do an in-person inspection of their documents.
If your company participates in E-Verify in good standing, you can examine documents remotely using the DHS alternative procedure: review copies, hold a live video call with the employee, keep the copies, and check the alternative-procedure box on the I-9. Use it consistently for all employees at the hiring site.
You can learn how to enroll in E-Verify and find more information on remote document checks and keeping records on the Remote Examination page.
The USCIS also offers an alternate method for examining documents.
Important: You need to complete Section 2 within 3 business days of the employee’s start date. If you’re late, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) could fine you.
To fill out the form with a remote employee, follow these steps.
Check the full rules for getting, checking, and keeping copies of employee documents on the ICE website.
Have your employee fill out Section 1 of the I-9 by their start date.
We'll create the form and make it available in their account if you make that selection during onboarding.
Within 3 business days of the employee's start date (or by the first day, if the job lasts less than 3 business days), you or an authorized representative need to check the employee's ID and work documents and fill out Section 2.
What to look for: A document is acceptable if it reasonably appears to be genuine, relates to the employee, and is unexpired.
Authorized representative: Anyone you authorize to complete and sign Section 2 on the company's behalf.
Get line-by-line guidance for completing Section 2 from ICE.
Double-check that every field is filled out and that the information is correct, then sign the form.
Keep the signed I-9 for three years after the date of hire, or one year after employment ends — whichever is later. Copying documents is optional unless you use the remote alternative procedure. If you copy documents, do so for every employee and keep the copies with the I-9.
If you chose not to send the form to the employee through Gusto: their onboarding checklist will include an option to upload the form to their profile.
You can store the documents in Gusto. Check out our articles with steps for admins and steps for employees.
Gusto's remote verification tool automates the Section 2 review for a remote employee. Instead of you arranging an authorized representative yourself, your employee nominates a reviewer in Gusto who acts as your authorized representative. You remain responsible for Section 2.
Note: Remote verification is available on Premium plans at no extra cost. On other plans, each verification costs $20 and appears on your invoice.
You indicate your I-9 verification method when you get to the Set up Gusto features task of the new hire's onboarding checklist.
After you send the invitation, you cannot change the verification method.
To use Gusto's remote verification tool:
Go to the new hire's onboarding checklist.
Find the Set up Gusto features task and click Start.
Scroll to Employment eligibility (Form I-9).
If you've used remote verification at this location before, it's selected by default.
Select Edit to change it — this also updates the default for future hires at that location.
If this is your first hire at this location, choose from four options: Gusto handles verification through E-Verify, An authorized representative verifies in person, You verify in person, or Handle verification outside of Gusto. Select An authorized representative verifies in person. Review the pricing and click Save and continue.
Important: Gusto defaults to the same I-9 verification method for each work location. Using a consistent method across employees at the same location also helps demonstrate nondiscriminatory practices. This is why we default to remote verification once you've used it at a location. All remote locations in a state count as one location, but each physical office is treated separately.
Select any other Gusto features you want to set up for this employee, then click Save and continue.
The employee will receive an email letting them know to access Gusto and complete their onboarding. Once the review is complete, the onboarding checklist item is marked as done. If you use E-Verify, you still need to create a case or use the integrated Gusto experience by the third business day after the employee’s start date.
Once an admin selects remote verification for a new hire, the employee follows the steps below to complete their part.
Step 1: Fill out I-9 documentation
To fill out the I-9:
Go to the I-9 section of your onboarding. Review and agree to the conditions, then select Start. Your personal information from onboarding is pre-filled.
Select your citizenship status and choose your identity document type (for example, a U.S. passport). Enter the document's expiration date and document number.
Upload clear photos of your document. After you attach the image and fill out all document details, select Next.
Indicate whether a preparer or translator helped you complete the form, then select Next.
Provide your signature. Select Finish to submit your I-9 information.
Step 2: Complete the in-person review
After you submit the form, a designated reviewer needs to review your work authorization documents in person.
The reviewer can be a family member or anyone other than you who meets these requirements:
Is 18 or older
Is physically present with you
Has a mobile device with internet access and a web browser
To complete the in-person review:
When prompted, allow location sharing. This confirms that you and your reviewer are in the same place.
Enter your reviewer's mobile phone number and select Send text message. They'll get a text with a link to start the review.
Note: International phone numbers are not supported.
Have your reviewer scan the QR code from the text message to access the review portal.
Your reviewer examines your original documents in person, confirms they match the uploaded images, certifies their identity, and attests to the review.
After your reviewer finishes, your part is complete.
When you add a new hire, you choose how to verify their work eligibility. If you choose E-Verify, Gusto guides your new hire through nominating a reviewer who acts as your authorized representative, completes the paperwork in Gusto, and creates the case in your E-Verify account. You remain responsible for Section 2.
E-Verify is available only with remote verification, not with in-person verification. Before you can use it, you need to connect your E-Verify account. Follow the steps in Connect E-Verify to Gusto below.
You can choose from four verification methods:
Gusto handles verification through E-Verify: $25 per team member, included with the Premium plan
An authorized representative verifies in person: $20 per team member, included with the Premium plan
You verify in person
Handle verification outside of Gusto
To choose E-Verify for a new hire:
Go to the new hire’s onboarding checklist.
Find the Set up Gusto features task and click Start.
Scroll to Employment eligibility (Form I-9).
Select Gusto handles verification through E-Verify.
If your company is not connected to E-Verify yet, select Connect to E-Verify and follow the steps in Connect E-Verify to Gusto below.
Finish the remaining sections.
Send the invitation.
After you choose a verification method for one hire, it becomes the default for future hires at that work location. You can change it for any new hire.
Important: If your company uses E-Verify, you must create a case for every new hire at that hiring site, not only for employees whose documents raise questions.
Your new hire completes both sections of Form I-9 through Gusto. For Section 2, they nominate a reviewer who:
Is with them in person
Examines their original documents
Acts as your authorized representative
When both sections are done, we create the E-Verify case automatically.
If the case has no issues, you will not see a task. The I-9 step is marked done on the employee’s onboarding checklist.
If a case needs action, you get a notification and a to-do on your dashboard, plus an email. Follow the steps in Manage E-Verify cases below.
Service
Other plans
Premium plan
Remote verification (an authorized representative completes Section 2)
$20 per team member
Included
E-Verify with remote verification
$25 per team member ($20 plus $5 for E-Verify)
Included
Charges appear on your invoice.
If you complete Form I-9 more than three business days after the start date, fill out the form as soon as you can and write down why it was delayed. If U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) checks your records, they might fine you, and the fines could get bigger with each mistake. It's important to finish these forms quickly and fix any delays right away.
The type of documentation you need to prove employment eligibility depends on the employee's status in the United States. Documents need to be current and not expired.
For more info on these requirements, check out the official I-9 form on the government website.
A citizen is someone born in the United States (including Puerto Rico, Guam, the U.S. Virgin Islands, and the Northern Mariana Islands), naturalized, or who became a citizen through a parent.

A lawful permanent resident is someone who is not a United States citizen and who resides under legally recognized and lawfully recorded permanent residence as an immigrant.

This includes anyone authorized to work in the United States but is not a United States citizen, United States national, or lawful permanent resident.

A noncitizen national is someone born in American Samoa, certain former citizens of the former Trust Territory of the Pacific Islands, and certain children of noncitizen nationals born abroad.

If a document does not appear genuine or does not seem to relate to the employee presenting it, you have a few options:
Request different documentation. Allow the employee to present other acceptable documents from List A, or a combination of List B and List C. You cannot require them to provide a specific document — the employee chooses what to present. Do not treat employees differently based on their citizenship, immigration status, or national origin.
Accept a receipt temporarily. If the original document was lost, stolen, or damaged, an employee may present a receipt for a replacement document. They must provide the actual replacement document within 90 days.
Designate an authorized representative. You can assign a personnel officer, agent, or notary public to examine documents and complete Section 2 on your behalf. You remain liable for any violations.
If your company uses E-Verify, you must create a case for every new hire at that hiring site, not only for employees whose documents raise questions.
If the employee still can't provide acceptable documents, do not complete Section 2 and do not begin or continue employment. Knowingly hiring or retaining unauthorized workers can result in civil fines and criminal prosecution.
Pilot: E-Verify in Gusto is still being improved. We know connecting your account takes several steps, and some customers need to create a new E-Verify account first. We’re working on ways to make this easier. If you run into trouble, select Report an issue in the Connect E-Verify window and tell us what happened.
E-Verify is a free online system. It checks if new employees can legally work in the United States.
Use this section if your company uses E-Verify, whether your state or contract requires it or you choose to have Gusto handle verification for a remote hire. Expand the sections below to learn about E-Verify, enroll, connect your account to Gusto, and manage cases.
To choose E-Verify for a remote hire, follow the steps in Have Gusto handle verification through E-Verify.
E-Verify is free to use. Enrollment takes only minutes, but your account is not active until your program administrator completes E-Verify’s training. It's available 24 hours a day and gives instant results.
Who needs to use E-Verify
Federal contractors must use E-Verify for all employees.
21 states require E-Verify for some or all employers: Alabama, Arizona, Florida, Georgia, Idaho, Indiana, Louisiana, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, Nebraska, North Carolina, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Virginia, and West Virginia.
Learn more about E-Verify
Main website: www.E-Verify.gov
Program information
User manuals
Employee rights information
"E-Verify Overview" (1 hour) - Complete program training
"E-Verify in 30" (30 minutes) - Quick overview
FAQs
Q: Can I save my enrollment progress?
A: No. You must complete enrollment in one session.
Q: How long does enrollment take?
A: Most companies receive confirmation within minutes.
Q: Do I need special software?
A: No. You only need a web browser and internet access.
Q: What if my company is already enrolled?
A: To connect to Gusto, your account needs Web Service Access under Company Account > Manage Users. If it does, connect your account. If it does not, E-Verify cannot upgrade it, so you need to create a new Web Services – Employer account. Cases from your current account stay there. If you’re not sure whether your company is enrolled, check the employer search tool at E-Verify.gov first.
Q: Can I use my regular E-Verify login in Gusto?
A: No. Your E-Verify login is for you. Gusto needs a separate Web services user so we can send your new hires’ information to E-Verify on your behalf. Create it in E-Verify under Company Account > Manage Users.
Q: I forgot my Web services password. What do I do?
A: E-Verify does not display it. To set a new one:
Sign in to E-Verify.
Go to Company Account > Manage Users > Web Service Access.
Open your Web services user.
Select Change password.
Enter the new password in Gusto.
To reset the password for your regular E-Verify login, go to e-verify.gov and select Forgot Password.
Q: I already did E-Verify training for my old account. Do I have to do it again?
A: Possibly. You can call E-Verify at 1-888-464-4218 and ask whether they can give you credit and waive the training for your new account. E-Verify decides whether it can be skipped.
Important: You must complete enrollment in one session. You cannot save your progress.
Connecting E-Verify to Gusto? Enroll as Web Services – Employer. This is the only account type that can connect to Gusto. Existing E-Verify accounts cannot be upgraded. For the full steps, including how to create the Web services user, follow the steps in Connect E-Verify to Gusto.
Step 1: Gather required information
You'll need the following info to enroll:
Company legal name
Federal Tax ID Number
Company address
Number of current employees
NAICS code (industry code)
Program Administrator contact info
Signatory contact info
Step 2: Enroll
To enroll on the E-Verify website:
On the Use Agreement page, click I Agree to consent to the terms.
Enter your email address.
Go to your email inbox and click the activation link.
Choose your account type. Select Web Services – Employer. E-Verify may label a different account type as the most common choice. Do not select it, because it cannot connect to Gusto.
Enter company information.
Add hiring site locations.
Add a program administrator and signatory.
Review and submit.
You will receive: Email confirmation within minutes.
Step 3: After enrolling
Three more steps are required after you enroll:
Your company's program administrator needs to complete E-Verify's online training. Your account is not active until the training is done.
Display E-Verify posters at your workplace.
Create your Web services user:
Sign in to E-Verify.
Go to Manage Users > Add Access.
Select the Web Services Access user role.
Create the user.
Set its password from the confirmation page.
If you completed training for a prior E-Verify account, you can call E-Verify at 1-888-464-4218 and ask whether they can give you credit and waive the new-account training.
When you’re done, connect your account. Follow the steps in Connect E-Verify to Gusto.
E-Verify is the U.S. government system for confirming a new hire’s eligibility to work. When you connect it to Gusto, we create E-Verify cases from your new hires’ remote I-9s. You only need to set this up once.
You need three things from E-Verify:
An E-Verify account set up as Web Services – Employer. This account type lets software like Gusto connect to E-Verify. A standard employer account cannot be used.
A Web services user in that account. This is a separate user ID and password made just for Gusto. It is not the login you use to sign in to E-Verify.
Program administrator access in E-Verify. You need it to create the Web services user.
Follow the steps under If your E-Verify account does not have Web Service Access below. Your account is not active until the training is done, so you cannot connect on the same day you enroll. When you’re done, come back to Gusto and follow the steps under Where to connect below.
First, check whether your account has Web Service Access.
To check your account:
Sign in to E-Verify.
Go to Company Account > Manage Users.
Look for Web Service Access.
If you see Web Service Access and already have a Web services user, follow the steps under Where to connect below. If you see Web Service Access but do not have a Web services user yet, follow the steps under Create a Web services user below. If you do not see it, follow the steps under If your E-Verify account does not have Web Service Access below.
E-Verify cannot upgrade or convert an existing account, so you need to create a new Web Services – Employer account. Cases from your current account stay there. If you do not have an E-Verify account yet, follow the same steps.
To create a Web Services – Employer account:
Go to the E-Verify enrollment page.
Select Enroll now.
Follow the registration prompts.
Select Web Services – Employer as the account type. E-Verify may label a different account type as the most common choice. Do not select it, because it cannot connect to Gusto.
Complete E-Verify’s required account setup and training.
After the account is created, sign in to E-Verify.
Go to Manage Users > Add Access.
Select the Web Services Access user role.
Create the user.
On the confirmation page, select Change password.
Set a password that’s 8–14 characters.
Come back to Gusto and enter that user ID and password.
E-Verify may warn that you’re creating a duplicate account. You can continue.
Pro tip: Already completed E-Verify training for a prior account? You can call E-Verify at 1-888-464-4218 and ask whether they can give you credit and waive the training for the new account. E-Verify decides whether it can be skipped.
Use these steps if your account has Web Service Access but no Web services user yet.
To create a Web services user:
Sign in to E-Verify as a program administrator.
Go to Company Account > Manage Users > Web Service Access.
Create a new user.
Open the user.
Select Change password.
Set a password that’s 8–14 characters.
Come back to Gusto and enter that user ID and password.
You can connect from your company settings or while adding a new hire.
To connect E-Verify from your company settings:
Go to Settings.
Select Customization.
Find the E-Verify row. This is separate from Employment verification.
Select Edit.
In the Connect E-Verify window, select Yes, I have an E-Verify account. If you do not have one yet, select No, I don’t have one yet and follow the steps under If you do not have an E-Verify account above.
Answer Have you created a Web services user? If you select Not yet or I’m not sure, follow the steps under Create a Web services user above.
Enter your connection details from E-Verify. Use the table below to find each one.
Select Connect E-Verify. The status shows Connecting to E-Verify… while we confirm your details.
To connect while adding a new hire, go to the Employment eligibility (Form I-9) step, select Gusto handles verification through E-Verify, then select Connect to E-Verify. Then follow steps 6–9 above.
Detail
Where to find it in E-Verify
Company ID
Company Account > Company Profile, under Company Information
Program administrator ID, first and last name, email, and phone
Company Account > Manage Users, then open your profile
Web services user ID and password
Company Account > Manage Users > Web Service Access
Important: Use your Web services user, not your E-Verify login. The username and password you use to sign in to E-Verify will not work in Gusto.
Never share your E-Verify username or password with anyone by phone, chat, or email, including Gusto support. Enter your credentials directly in Gusto. We will never ask for them any other way.
If your connection fails, check that:
You entered your Web services user ID and password, not your regular E-Verify login.
Your E-Verify account was set up as Web Services – Employer.
Your Company ID and program administrator details match what’s in E-Verify exactly, with no typos.
Still stuck? Select Report an issue in the Connect E-Verify window.
If an E-Verify case needs action, Gusto creates a to-do on your dashboard and E-Verify sends an email. Action-required cases are typically a mismatch between a document and what’s on file with E-Verify.
To review and resolve a case:
Click the dashboard notification to see the case type and resolution instructions.
Review the case. If an admin can resolve it, you’ll see resolution steps.
Complete the resolution steps.
Acknowledge the steps. We automatically reprocess the submission.
If the employee needs to act, they’ll see a dashboard to-do and can resolve it if the error is fixable.
Photo Match (resolved in Gusto)
Gusto prompts you to compare the employee’s photo document with the photo displayed when the E-Verify case was created. This helps confirm the document matches Department of Homeland Security (DHS) records.
Four List A documents can trigger Photo Match:
U.S. passport
Passport card
Permanent Resident Card (Form I-551)
Employment Authorization Document (Form I-766)
If you select No, this photo does not match, E-Verify updates the case status to Scan and Upload.
Unconfirmed Data (resolved in your E-Verify account)
E-Verify asks you to confirm the information on the employee’s Form I-9.
To resolve Unconfirmed Data:
Review the information.
Confirm it’s correct, or update any incorrect fields.
Click Confirm and Send to E-Verify.
Gusto sends the corrections to E-Verify, but the Form I-9 in Gusto is not updated. Correct the I-9 and upload the corrected version to the employee’s profile. Learn how in Edit or correct Form I-9.
Scan and Upload (resolved in your E-Verify account)
E-Verify requests an image of the front and back of the document, or the ID and barcode pages of a passport or passport card. Click Send photos to E-Verify to submit the photos the employee already uploaded.
Manual Review (resolved in your E-Verify account)
E-Verify returns E-Verify Needs More Time, usually with a result within 24 hours and sometimes up to 3 federal business days. No action is needed. Check E-Verify for updates. Adverse action toward the employee is prohibited during this period.
Tentative Nonconfirmation (Mismatch) (resolved in your E-Verify account)
This shows in Gusto as E-Verify case Pending Referral (TNC). The employee’s information did not match Social Security Administration (SSA) records, Department of Homeland Security (DHS) records, or both. It does not mean the employee is unauthorized to work.
Complete these steps as soon as possible, and no later than 10 federal government working days after the mismatch is issued:
Review the Further Action Notice in E-Verify to see which agency reported the mismatch.
Notify the employee and give them the Further Action Notice.
Record whether the employee will take action to resolve the mismatch.
If they will, refer the case in E-Verify and give them the Referral Date Confirmation.
The employee then contacts DHS or visits an SSA field office, as the notice directs, by the date on the Referral Date Confirmation. If the employee chooses not to take action, or does not give you a decision within 10 federal government working days, close the case in E-Verify.
Final Nonconfirmation, FNC
E-Verify could not confirm work authorization after the appropriate agency reviewed the case. Review the result, determine next steps, and close the case in E-Verify. Do not take adverse action unless and until an FNC is issued, and follow all applicable federal requirements. More details from DHS.
Important: Do not take adverse action against an employee because of an E-Verify case result (such as terminating, suspending, delaying training, or reducing pay or hours). You may act only if the case receives a Final Nonconfirmation or the employee chooses not to take action on a mismatch. The employee must be allowed to keep working while they resolve a mismatch.
This information is general guidance, not legal advice. For help with a specific case, consult an employment attorney or Ask an HR Expert (available on eligible plans).
Q: Do I still have to sign in to E-Verify after setup?
A: Gusto handles most E-Verify tasks for you. You may still need to sign in to E-Verify to resolve a TNC, respond to a DHS or SSA request, or close certain case types. See the case types above.
Q: What happens if I do not resolve an E-Verify case?
A: You must resolve all cases, and most have a deadline. If you leave a case open, you may face consequences under your E-Verify agreement, including loss of E-Verify access, more scrutiny during audits, and, for federal contractors, possible debarment.
Q: What is the audit risk, and how do I protect my company?
A: Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) can audit your I-9 and E-Verify records at any time. Audits often start with a Notice of Inspection, which gives you 3 business days to provide records.
To protect your company:
Complete I-9s on time and keep them accurate.
Close E-Verify cases promptly.
Keep the signed I-9 for 3 years after the date of hire or 1 year after employment ends (whichever is later).
Fix errors as soon as you find them.
Keep records of your case results.
Q: My employee has not completed their I-9 after a few days. What now?
A: Employees must complete Section 1 by their first day of work. Section 2 must be completed within 3 business days of their start date.
If your employee has not finished:
Send a reminder right away.
Let them know you cannot submit their E-Verify case until they finish.
Document your follow-up.
If they still do not complete it, consider talking to an employment attorney or Ask an HR Expert (available on eligible plans). See also What to do if you complete Form I-9 late.
Help with Gusto
For help connecting E-Verify to Gusto or resolving a case in Gusto, select Report an issue in the Connect E-Verify window or contact Gusto support.
Contact E-Verify directly for questions about your E-Verify account, enrollment, or training.
E-Verify customer and technical support
Contact E-Verify for questions about E-Verify policies, Form I-9, and employment eligibility.
Phone: 1-888-464-4218
Email: [email protected]
Hours: Monday-Friday, 8 AM to 8 PM Eastern Time
Note: Contact information is subject to change. Always verify current contact details at E-Verify.gov.
Once you complete Form I-9, you can view it in an employee’s profile. You can also download all the I-9s Gusto has on file for your entire team.
To find a certain employee's I-9:
Go to People.
Click your employee's name.
Click Documents.
View the Form I-9.
Employees can also access and download this form at any time by going to the Documents tab in their own account.
To download all the I-9s Gusto has on file for your entire team:
Go to Documents.
Click Bulk downloads.
You can only generate a package once per day. Depending on the file size, your .zip file could take a while to create.
On the I-9 row, click Generate.
Wait for the I-9 package to generate.
If you download a package while the new package is still generating, you'll download the old file.
Once generated, click Download.
Pro Tip: If your company has a large number of employees, check back in about 5 minutes to see if your .zip file is ready for download.