This article is for admins who want to buy or manage workers’ compensation (workers’ comp) coverage through Gusto Agency. You can get a quote from The Hartford and buy a policy without leaving Gusto.
Note: This is now available to some customers and is rolling out to more customers over the coming weeks.
Gusto Agency is our licensed insurance agency. When you buy through Gusto Agency, we place your policy with an insurance carrier. The carrier issues your policy and bills your premiums. Gusto is not the insurance carrier.
You may see Gusto Insurance Services, LLC on your policy documents. This is the legal name of Gusto Agency.
In Gusto, you can get a workers’ comp quote from The Hartford and buy a policy. Licensed Gusto Agency agents can also compare quotes from other carriers, including AmTrust.
If your policy is with ERGO NEXT, ERGO NEXT still supports it. See Manage your company’s Workers’ Compensation with ERGO NEXT Insurance.
You can get a quote and buy a policy in Gusto when your company meets all of these criteria.
All of your employees work in one state
You have a single class code that the carrier accepts
The Hartford is willing to insure your business
A licensed Gusto Agency agent helps you instead in these cases.
You want a quote from a carrier other than The Hartford
You have employees in more than one state
You have more than one location
Your state requires a handwritten signature (Florida, New Hampshire, West Virginia, or Missouri)
You have prior claims
A carrier declines your business or needs to review it
Your class code does not fit a carrier
You ask for help
An agent follows up with you within one to three business days. If you do not hear from us, email [email protected].
To buy workers’ comp in Gusto, follow these steps.
Go to Taxes & compliance > Business insurance. On the workers’ compensation card, select Get a free quote.
Answer the questions about your business, like whether you had a workers’ comp claim in the last four years. We fill in the year your business was founded from the year you joined Gusto, and you can change it.
Add your owners. For each owner, enter their name, whether they work in the business day to day, their ownership stake, and their annual compensation. Ownership needs to add up to 100%. If a business or trust holds part of your company, select the checkbox for that.
Use the Covered under policy toggle to include or exclude each owner where your state allows it.
Wait while we finalize your recommendation. We review your quote with our carriers and confirm it lines up with your payroll data.
Review the coverage we recommend from The Hartford and the other coverage options. The options differ in their employer liability limits and whether they include a waiver of subrogation. Select the policy you want.
Review your coverage details, policy start date, how your team works, and where your employees work. Select the edit icon, or This isn’t how my team works, to make changes. Then select Continue to payment.
Review how you’ll be billed and your payment summary. Pay-as-you-go is the only option in the app today. Type your name as your electronic signature, and then select Get coverage now.
At any step, you can select Talk to a licensed agent if you need help.
You pay by bank account only. Credit cards are not accepted. You do not pay anything when you buy. The Hartford emails you a link to set up your payment method after you get coverage.
After you buy, the Almost there — one more step screen tells you your policy is issued but you still need to set up your account with The Hartford. We also send a “Your workers’ comp purchase is confirmed” email with your policy number, start date, and carrier contacts. These messages mean your policy is issued. They do not mean pay-as-you-go is fully set up yet, so follow the steps in the next section.
What you do next depends on your carrier.
The Hartford — Within 48 hours, you get an email from [email protected] with a link to set up your pay-as-you-go account in The Hartford’s secure portal. Use it to register and add your bank details. This step is required. If you do not set it up within 30 days, The Hartford moves you to a fixed payment plan. After you register, Hartford tells us, and we start sending your payroll to Hartford.
AmTrust — You have nothing else to do. We send your bank information to AmTrust, and AmTrust sets up everything.
If you excluded owners or officers, our sales team follows up with a form for you to sign. The form is required to keep the exclusion, and you may also need to submit it to your state. If you do not sign the form, your officers default to the state default, which usually means they are included in your policy. You can submit the form later, and we can update your policy to exclude them.
Gusto charges a Pay As You Go service fee of $1 per employee per month, capped at $5 per month, to set up and maintain the payroll integration with participating insurance carriers. Before you buy, you can see this fee as the Gusto service fee in your price breakdown.
Your premium is based on your payroll wages. The estimate in your policy details shows what you may pay over the policy year. Your carrier bills your premiums by taking payments from your bank account after payroll.
The Hartford — Hartford takes the payment within two to three business days after we send your payroll to Hartford.
AmTrust — We send your payroll data to AmTrust in a weekly file. AmTrust typically takes the payment the next business day after it gets the file, except around holidays. If you run payroll on a Monday, the payment can take about eight days.
Charges on your bank statement show the carrier’s name, not Gusto. Hartford charges show as “THE HARTFORD DES: PACERPYRLC.” AmTrust charges show as “AMTRUST NA.”
To see your policy in Gusto, go to Taxes & compliance > Business insurance. In the Current policies section, open your policy to see its details, like your estimated annual cost, billing type, and effective dates.
The Manage your policy button and the links in the Manage policy section open your carrier’s portal. Use the portal for proof of insurance, class codes, coverage, invoices, payment, and claims. The table below shows where to go for common tasks.
Task
The Hartford
AmTrust
Get a certificate of insurance
Use Hartford My Account.
Use the certificate request link or email [email protected]. This usually takes 24 – 48 hours.
See invoices and payment history
Use Hartford My Account.
Use the AmTrust insured portal (AmTrust Online).
Dispute a bill or ask for a refund
Call Hartford billing at 877-287-1316.
Email [email protected].
Update your bank account
Use Hartford My Account. Bank changes in Gusto do not sync to Hartford.
Email [email protected]. AmTrust needs a signed Direct Debit Authorization form.
Change your class codes
Use Hartford My Account.
Email [email protected].
Change policy or business information
Use Hartford My Account for many changes. For others, call Hartford at 866-467-8730.
Email [email protected].
File a claim
Use Hartford My Account or call 800-327-3636 (24/7).
Email [email protected] or call 888-239-3909 (24/7).
Finish an audit
Use Hartford My Account.
Use the AmTrust insured portal.
Cancel your policy
Use Hartford My Account.
Email [email protected]. You also need to sign a Lost Policy Release form to finish the cancellation.
Reinstate a canceled policy
Call Hartford at 866-467-8730.
Email [email protected].
Renew your policy
Hartford renews your policy automatically.
AmTrust renews your policy automatically about 90 days before it expires.
For questions about your coverage, or to add another policy, email [email protected].
If you already have a workers’ comp policy, you can transfer it to Gusto as your broker or keep your current broker. If you transfer, you can set up pay-as-you-go billing on your existing policy. Your coverage, carrier, and premium stay the same. Only the managing agency changes.
To transfer your policy to Gusto, follow these steps.
Go to Taxes & compliance. In the Tools section, find the Workers’ compensation card and select Setup now.
Select I already have coverage.
Select Transfer my policy to Gusto. If you would rather not transfer, select Keep my current broker. We track your policy in Gusto and send you renewal reminders.
Choose your carrier. You can choose AmTrust, The Hartford, Employers, CNA, or Berkshire Hathaway GUARD. Some carriers connect directly through Gusto, and others connect through our partner ERGO NEXT Insurance. If you do not see your carrier, select Request a carrier connection.
Confirm your policy details. We fill in your company name and address. Enter your policy number and your policy expiration date, and then select Continue.
Review and sign your transfer agreement. Type your full legal name as your electronic signature, and then select Submit transfer request.
By signing the transfer agreement, you agree to the following.
Name Gusto Insurance Services, LLC as the broker of record on your policy
Let your carrier debit pay-as-you-go premium payments from your bank account each pay period, based on your actual payroll
Confirm that nothing material has changed since your policy was issued, including your ownership or entity structure, what your team does, your locations and states, or your payroll and headcount by more than 25%
Notify Gusto and your carrier if anything changes before the transfer is processed
Pay the pay-as-you-go service fee and let Gusto share payroll data with your carrier to calculate premiums
After you submit, a licensed agent reviews your signed transfer form within two business days. If the agent needs more information, like state-required officer exclusion forms, they reach out. We email you a status update when a decision has been made.
A transfer typically takes one to five business days. Your current broker has to release your policy with your consent first, and then we process the transfer. It can take up to 15 business days.
You cannot transfer a policy that is with ERGO NEXT to Gusto Agency.
Pay-as-you-go coverage needs regular payroll. What happens if payroll stops depends on your carrier.
The Hartford — Hartford needs your first payroll within 30 days of your coverage start date. Hartford emails you reminders to set up your portal and when it has not received payroll. If Hartford does not receive payroll, it moves your policy to an annual or fixed monthly payment plan and sends you a bill. Your policy is not canceled. You can move back to pay-as-you-go if you contact us within 14 days of the move and have not paid the bill.
AmTrust — AmTrust does not move policies to a payment plan. It can cancel a policy for nonpayment. AmTrust notifies us monthly, and we contact you if we need your help. If you have been setting up your policy for more than 30 days with no progress, or you do not respond to us, we may ask AmTrust to cancel your policy.
If something looks wrong, email [email protected].
Q: Is Gusto the insurance carrier?
A: No. Gusto Agency is your insurance agent. The carrier issues your policy and bills your premiums.
Q: Why can I not see this in Gusto?
A: This is available to some customers now and rolling out to more over the coming weeks.
Q: What if my policy is with ERGO NEXT?
A: ERGO NEXT supports all policies it sold and all policies with ERGO NEXT as the carrier, including policies Gusto Agency sold. See Manage your company’s Workers’ Compensation with ERGO NEXT Insurance.
Q: Can I cover contractors (1099s)?
A: Yes, but only through a licensed Gusto Agency agent, and only on direct bill. You cannot buy contractor coverage in the app. Email [email protected] to get started.
Q: Which states are not covered?
A: Ohio, Washington, North Dakota, and Wyoming are monopolistic states, which means workers’ comp there comes from the state fund and not from Gusto Agency or ERGO NEXT. Gusto Agency does not currently sell in Michigan. If your business is in Michigan, you can get coverage through ERGO NEXT insurance agents.
Q: Who do I contact with questions?
A: For questions about your coverage or your Gusto Agency policy, email [email protected]. For claims, bills, and certificates of insurance, contact your carrier using the table in Manage your policy.