At this time, Gusto only supports non-statutory stock options (NSOs).
Use the information below to learn how to record these transactions in Gusto so they are reported on Form W-2.
Make sure to record these transactions before Dec 31 for accurate year-end filings.
In addition to wages, salaries, and commissions, you need to include other forms of compensation, like stock options, in an employee’s gross income. An NSO (also known as a non-qualified stock option) gives employees an option to buy company stock at a fixed price for a certain period of time, with fewer conditions than statutory stock options.
We do not currently support statutory stock options, like Incentive Stock Options (ISOs) and Employee Stock Purchase Plans (ESPPs). Consult a certified public accountant (CPA) or tax advisor for help meeting these requirements.
When an employee exercises vested NSOs, their gross income includes the spread, which is the difference between the stock’s fair market value and the option’s exercise price. The spread is subject to income and employment taxes, and it appears on the employee’s Form W-2. No Internal Revenue Code section 83(b) election applies to the exercise of vested options.
To make sure income from the exercise of NSOs gets reported accurately on the W-2, you need to take both of these actions.
Record the transaction in Gusto using one of the methods below.
Record the transaction when you go through your tax checklist near the end of the year so it appears on the W-2.
You can add the spread from the exercise to the employee’s gross income in Gusto with one of two methods. Expand the sections below to see when to use each method.
Use this method when an equity platform, like Pulley or Carta, handled the exercise. This method records the income on the exercise date and lets us pay the taxes.
Go to our article on how to report a non-Gusto payroll.
When you report NSOs with the non-Gusto payroll tool, keep these points in mind.
If your accountant or other third-party provider gave you specific tax amounts for this transaction, you can edit the tax amounts the non-Gusto payroll tool provides.
This includes setting federal income tax, state income tax, or both to $0.
Add the NSO amount as gross wages in the non-Gusto payroll.
In the Tax payments step, select I need Gusto to pay this tax next to each tax you want us to pay. When you review and submit, choose a debit date so we can collect the funds and pay the taxes on your behalf.
If the equity platform collected only the 22% federal estimate, you need to recover the shortfall with a post-tax deduction on a later paycheck.
Use this method when the employee has enough wages on a regular payroll to cover the added taxes from the stock option. If the wages do not cover the taxes, or you have no more regular payrolls to run this year, use a non-Gusto payroll instead.
To report the exercise with a regular payroll, follow these steps.
Set up a separate Other (taxable) benefit for each employee who exercised options. Do not use a shared benefit with a $0 amount.
Name it “Stock Options” or something similar for reporting purposes.
Enter the actual taxable value of the stock as the Company Contribution.
Set the Employee Deduction to $0.
Run a regular payroll with this benefit active.
After the payroll runs, remove the benefit from the employee’s profile so it does not apply to future payrolls.
Income from the exercise of non-statutory stock options gets added to the W-2 boxes listed below.
Box 1: Wages, tips, and other compensation
Box 3 (up to the Social Security wage base): Social Security wages
Box 5: Medicare wages and tips
Box 12 with Code V: Income from the exercise of non-statutory stock option(s)
This must be added manually as special compensation. You'll be prompted to add it in your account before we file W-2s.
Box 16 (reporting requirements vary by state): State wages, tips, etc.
Box 18 (reporting requirements vary by local): Local wages, tips, etc.